A Fairytale in New York?
A 33-Year-Old Muslim Democratic Socialist Is About to Become New York’s Next Mayor: and predictably the GOP and Israel Lobby are absolutely losing their merry shit over it
In a political earthquake that’s sent shockwaves through both the Democratic establishment and the Republican right, 33-year-old Zohran Mamdani is on track to become the next Mayor of New York City. A Muslim, an Indian-Ugandan immigrant, and an openly declared democratic socialist, Mamdani’s victory in the Democratic primary is more than just historic: it’s a direct challenge to the entrenched interests of the political centre, the billionaire class, and the pro-Israel lobby that has long exerted quiet but enormous influence over American politics. The backlash from conservatives, centrist Democrats, and Israel-aligned organisations has been swift and venomous, a sure sign that Mamdani’s rise has rattled the foundations of the status quo.
Zohran Mamdani’s journey from immigrant child to mayor-in-waiting is the kind of narrative American politicians love, except this one comes wrapped in unapologetically radical politics. Born in Kampala, Uganda, and raised between Africa and New York, Mamdani came to politics through community organising, tenant rights activism, and a stint as a foreclosure-prevention counsellor. A former hip-hop artist and the son of filmmaker Mira Nair, he’s not your average city hall climber, and that’s precisely why his candidacy has taken off. At just 33, Mamdani has galvanised a powerful coalition across working-class communities, especially among younger voters, people of colour, and immigrant neighbourhoods. His campaign promises read like a love letter to the Bernie left: rent freezes, fare-free public transport, public ownership of essential services like grocery stores, and a steep taxation policy targeting the super-rich. Far from alienating voters, his honesty about class politics and redistribution has struck a nerve in a city ravaged by inequality and gentrification.
And that’s exactly why the knives are out.
The AIPAC Smear Machine Comes for Mamdani
It didn’t take long after Zohran Mamdani’s primary victory for AIPAC and its affiliates to sharpen their knives. Within hours, coordinated statements, Twitter campaigns, and op-eds began flooding the discourse all painting Mamdani as a dangerous extremist with a 'deeply troubling' record on Israel. The smear campaign is formulaic by now: take a principled stand for Palestinian rights, and watch as your words are distorted, your character maligned, and your motives called into question. AIPAC’s particular obsession with Mamdani stems from one thing: he doesn’t equivocate. He has called Israel’s decades-long military occupation what it is: apartheid. He has supported the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement as a legitimate, non-violent tool of resistance. He has spoken plainly about US military complicity in the bombing of Gaza, and he’s attended rallies demanding an end to unconditional aid to Israel. For AIPAC and their allies, that alone is unforgivable. Rather than engage on substance, AIPAC has opted for character assassination. They’ve accused Mamdani of 'endorsing terrorism' for using slogans like 'Globalise the Intifada' ignoring that the phrase, in activist contexts, calls for global solidarity with grassroots resistance movements, not violence. They’ve tried to tie him to antisemitism without any credible evidence, a now-standard tactic used against Black, brown, and Muslim politicians who dare criticise Israel. It’s the same playbook they used on Ilhan Omar, Rashida Tlaib, and Bernie Sanders’ campaign surrogates: smear first, clarify never. The irony, of course, is that Mamdani has been consistently clear in condemning antisemitism, while standing in solidarity with Jews and others fighting for Palestinian human rights. But AIPAC isn’t interested in nuance, only in enforcing red lines. In their eyes, any public official who doesn’t tow the pro-Israel line must be politically destroyed. But this time, the old playbook may not work. Mamdani’s base knows exactly what’s happening. They’ve seen this script before, the deliberate conflation of anti-Zionism with antisemitism, the way accusations are deployed not to protect Jewish communities, but to silence criticism of a state engaged in ethnic cleansing. And rather than retreat, Mamdani’s supporters are doubling down, proudly backing a candidate who won’t sell out Palestinian lives to appease the donor class. If AIPAC thought they could bully Mamdani into silence, they’ve badly misread the moment. The smear campaign isn’t weakening his support, it’s fuelling a broader awakening. And if Mamdani walks into Gracie Mansion this November, it won’t just be a personal victory, it’ll be a defeat for the politics of intimidation that AIPAC has trafficked in for far too long.
GOP Panic and the Red-Baiting Revival
If you want to know just how rattled the American right is by Zohran Mamdani, look no further than the hysterical response from the GOP. The moment it became clear that a Muslim democratic socialist had won the Democratic primary in the biggest city in the country, the Republican Party snapped into Cold War mode, only this time, the bogeyman isn’t in Moscow. He’s in Queens, wears sneakers, and wants to cap your rent.
Donald Trump, never one to miss a racist dog-whistle opportunity, took to Truth Social to brand Mamdani a '100% communist lunatic' and warned that New York would become a 'third-world hellhole' under his watch. Fox News followed with breathless coverage about 'Sharia law' 'Antifa candidates' and 'radical Islamist's taking over the Democrat party. Right-wing influencers scraped Mamdani’s old rap lyrics for anything that could be twisted into a security threat, and Tucker Carlson called him 'more dangerous than AOC, and even less American'. It’s textbook red-baiting, with a dash of Islamophobia and a heavy dose of McCarthyite panic. The fact that Mamdani is an immigrant, a practicing Muslim, and a vocal opponent of the police-industrial complex makes him the perfect projection screen for every right-wing fear fantasy. They’re not just smearing him as a socialist, they’re casting him as a foreign infiltrator, a sleeper cell for the radical left, and a threat to the American way of life. The subtext isn't even subtle: how dare a man like that rise to lead a city like this?
But the GOP’s problem with Mamdani isn’t really about ideology. It’s about precedent. If he wins in New York on a platform of taxing the rich, defunding the NYPD, backing tenants over landlords, and calling Israel an apartheid state then others like him will follow. He represents the future they’re terrified of: a young, multiracial, working-class left that doesn’t need the approval of billionaires, police unions, or party bosses to win. That’s why the smears are so vicious. Because Mamdani doesn’t fit the part they wrote for him. He’s not apologising. He’s not triangulating. He’s not running to the centre. He’s winning on the left: and unapologetically so. And if there’s one thing the modern GOP can’t stand, it’s someone who beats them without playing their rigged game.
So let them foam at the mouth. Let them call him a terrorist, a Marxist, a threat to the republic. The more they scream, the more obvious it becomes: the real threat to their power isn’t Mamdani himself, it’s the movement that’s carrying him to City Hall. A movement that sees through their lies, rejects their fear, and is finally building power of its own.
And of course they hate him for it, and that means he's doing something right. But a note of caution: like Robert Kennedy before him, that puts him firmly in the crosshairs. After all, the land of the free despises people who demand freedom, and even moreso if they have the possibility of achieving it.
A bit of shameless self-plugging here. This is www.TetleysTLDR.com blog. It's not monitised. Please feel feel to go and look at the previous ones on the website and if you like them, please feel free to share them.
